Thursday, February 7, 2008

Early and Middle Bronze Age Characteristics

Canaanite City-States and Urbanism in Palestine

Overview:
Early Bronze Age—3500 to 2200
Middle of the Period--Cultural hegemony of Sumer and Akkad and Old Kingdom Egypt—Begins with the rise of Egypt and Sumer, development of writing, urbanism, monarchy.
Ends with the decline of the Old Kingdom and Sumer at Ur III—meanwhile the beginnings of Minoan civilization in Greece.
Intermediate (EB IV or MB I) to Middle Bronze Age—2200 to 1550 is circumscribed by the Fall of Ur III and the Hyksos invasions of Egypt—Egypt still retained cultural influence over the Levant but Egypt itself was in disarray and alternately ruled by their “Asiatic” or “Semitic” overlords
Meanwhile toward end of this period Mycenaean civilization arises in Greece.
Early Bronze Age Palestine For whatever reason, Palestine lagged behind Mesopotamia and northern Syria in the development of a complex society.
Nevertheless, the rise of urbanism is a hallmark of the Early Bronze Age (3200-2200 BC) in Palestine. The chronology of Early Bronze Palestine is tied to that of Egypt, but there is disagreement over the terminology and dates for the period.
Egyptian finds in Palestine indicate that the Early Bronze (EB) I correlates to the late Predynastic Period and the beginning of the First Dynasty in Egypt, while the EB II correlates to the remainder of the Archaic Period (Dynasties 1-2), and the EB III corresponds to the Old Kingdom (Dynasties 3-6).

The Rise of Urbanism: The EB I Period (3200-3000 BC)
True urbanism only arose after an initial transitional phase, usually called EB I (3330-3000 BC), in which most settlements were unfortified villages. These were generally in different locations than in the preceding Chalcolithic period. Another innovation is the introduction of tombs in which large numbers of skeletons are found together in a natural or hewn-out rock cave.

Such tombs, in fact, are the main source of data for the period. Often, the skeletons are found disarticulated—perhaps indicating secondary burials—ususally with the skulls lined up next to a central bone pile. A huge cemetery at Bab edh-Dhra, at the Lisan peninsula on the east side of the Dead Sea, represents the largest burial ground of this type known in the Near East. A settlement nearby seems too small to accommodate such a cemetery. This has led to the hypothesis that Bab edh-Dhra served as a regional cemetery with sacred associations. Another theory holds that the cemetery served the “cities of the Plain,” including the lost cities of Sodom and Gommorrah (Gen 13:10-12), but this is quite uncertain.

At Bab edh-Dhra, two types of EB I tombs are known. Earlier “shaft tombs,” with multiple secondary burials in an artificial cave reached by a vertical shaft, give way to built up structures of mud brick containing multiple primary burials. Similar to the latter are round stonebuilt tombs with corbelled roofs found in the southern Sinai, called nawamis, apparently built by pastoral nomads.

The major public buildings known from EB I Palestine are temples. A double sanctuary at Megiddo, separated from dwellings by a walled courtyard, may have served as a central shrine for the area. Temples are known from other sites, including Hartuv, where a large broad hall sanctuary incorporating a row of standing stones (Hebrew massebot) may have developed from an open-air sacred area.

Urban Palestine: The EB II-III Period (3000-2200 BC)
With the Early Bronze II period urbanism fully arrived in Paleistine, spurred on, no doubt, by peaking trade relations with Egypt, evidenced already in the EB I period. Large walled cities appeared at Ai, Arad, Beth Yerah, Megiddo, Tell el-Farcah, Yarmuth, and other sites.The fortifications at EB II-III sites are quite impressive. EB II walls were usually entered through narrow gates and reinforced with projecting semi-circular towers as seen in an excellent example at Arad, in the eastern Negev. In the late EB II and EB III periods walls were generally thickened, at Ai and Beth Yerah (Khirbet Kerak) eventually reaching a width of eight meters. At Yarmuth, continued constructions swelled the defensive perimeter enclosing forty acres to a width of forty meters!

In contrast to Mesopotamia, the actual history of the cities in EB Palestine is completely unknown, as no inscriptional material has yet been found. There were connections between Egyptian incursions in the south of Palestine and their construction, but the cities of EB Palestine seem never to have developed a unified political system. Indeed, the fortifications and other features imply a system of large city-states. They were, apparently, the beginnings of the royal Canaanite system of independent, rival states which continued into the next millennium. They may have been in mutual competition or conflict, as occasional destruction levels seem to indicate.The city wall at Jericho, for example, was rebuilt seventeen times during the Early Bronze Age.

Fall of Urbanism: The EB IV/MB I Period (2300-2000 B.C.E.)
The last two centuries of the third millennium BC in Palestine are marked by the wholesale destruction or abandonment of every major EB III site in Palestine. The subsequent period, in contrast to those great city-states, is characterized by a seminomadic, pastoral way of life. This period is comparable to the First Intermediate Period of Egypt, and represents a dark age for Palestine. The MB I pottery shows more characteristics in common with the preceding Early Bronze than with the Middle Bronze IIA which follows. Therefore, some have preferred to call this period EB IV. As we have seen, the interlude of the MB I period also saw a disruption of centralized control in Egypt.The transhumant population of Palestine was feared and loathed by Egyptians.

Negative though it may be, there are similarities between this attitude and the lifestyle described of the Patriarchs in the Bible. Although there have been attempts to place Abraham in the MB I Period, it is far more likely that the age of the Patriarchs should be sought in the early 2nd millennium BC—the Middle Bronze Age. Sometimes referred to as the Intermediate Bronze Age, marks a dramatic transformation in the urbanization and the growth of societies, which were originally established at the beginning of EB I through to the EB III.

Severe drought resulting from a major climatic catastrophe(s) that occurred circa 2300-2200 B.C.E. (EB IV/MB I) encompassed the whole region of the Near East.

The Age of Internationalism: The Middle Bronze Age (2200 - 1570 B.C.E.)
The Middle Bronze Age is contemporary with the First Intermediate Period, Middle Kingdom and Second Intermediate Period in Egypt. United Egypt of the Old Kingdom disintegrated into individual kingdoms (nomarchs) after the Sixth Dynasty. This period of disunity, possibly described in the Admonitions of Ipuwer (ANET, pp.441-444), lasted some three hundred years and is generally contemporary with Middle Bronze I.

Under kings of the Twelfth and Thirteenth Dynasty, Middle Kingdom Egypt reached a cultural pinnacle. Politically Middle Kingdom monarchs extended their influence southward into Nubia as far as the fortress of Semnah. Egypt's hegemony in Asia, however, is more problematic, although there is evidence of early contact with Asiatic peoples. The Tale of Sinuhe describes the adventures of an Egyptian royal tutor who fled to Syria and lived among the Asiatic tribes. Other evidence of contact include Egyptian execration texts, lists of Asiatics living in Egyptian households, extensive gifts and statuary from Byblos and other sites, and Egyptian tomb inscriptions and depictions (e.g. Beni Hasan painting of 37 Asiatics).

Asiatics gained control of the delta region of Egypt in the Second Intermediate Period. Known as the Hyksos “Rulers of Foreign Lands” these Asiatic princes may have extended control beyond the delta and as far south as Abydos. A number of key battles were fought by Egyptian kings of the Seventeenth Dynasty against the Hyksos but it wasn't until the reign of Amosis, the first king of the Eighteenth Dynasty (circa 1570 B.C.E.), that the Hyksos were expelled.

Albright, Nelson Glueck and E. A. Speiser, have linked the Patriarchs to the end of Middle Bronze I and beginning of Middle Bronze II.

More Chronologies and Milestones


Click on the chart for Late Neolithic to Middle Bronze Age milestones and events.

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

Prehistory of the Levant


The economic specializations that still sustain people living in the Middle East began in prehistory. From the Paleolithic to the Neolithic, the cultivation of wheat, lentils, barley and, later, olives, grapes and dates, developed along with the domestication of goats and sheep. Click on the chart to get a closer look at these and other milestones for each of the important prehistoric periods.





Thursday, January 10, 2008

Archaeological Orientations and Methods in the Land of the Bible

Classical and Near Eastern archaeologists have found themselves to be quite comfortable working in Israel, Jordan and the Palestinian Authority. One group that is still underrepresented, however, is that of anthropological archaeologists. Anthropologists make up only a small percentage of the membership of the major research institutes and, while their participation is growing, most of them do not work on Biblical sites.

Work in the lands of the Bible has produced some defining moments in the history of archaeological method. Flinders Petrie began working in Palestine in 1890 and developed his system of constructing chronological sequences based upon pottery, recovered from different strata of an archaeological site, partly because of his work there. There was very little interest in pottery by his contemporaries but versions of his approach have found their way into the practice of archaeology globally. William Foxwell Albright’s method of interpreting and incorporating historical resources into the study of artifacts and sites has become a part of historical archaeological approaches worldwide. Albright, working in the Holy Land from the 1920’s forward, brought together Biblical, Near Eastern, historical and archaeological scholarship in a way that had never been accomplished by previous researchers.

Methods of site excavation, specifically adapted to “tell” environments (see illustration) have been a primary concern from all Near Eastern Archaeologists. The traditional technique of recovering complete architectural units, referred to as the “architectural layers” approach, focused on the horizontal exposure of important features as they were discovered. Every effort was made to recover the extant remains of such features before proceeding to lower layers. This approach has been particularly useful for researchers interested in defining the plans of monumental buildings like palaces, temples and fortifications. It is also important for sites that will be presented to the public.

In the fifties and sixties, in excavations at Jericho and the City of David, Kathleen Kenyon introduced an alternative practice. The so-called Wheeler-Kenyon Method (having been first developed by Kenyon’s mentor Mortimer Wheeler) is concerned largely with the vertical rather than the horizontal dimension. This method divides the excavation space into a grid of five-meter squares with two-meter wide walls (called “balks”) in between. The squares are excavated down to bedrock in carefully recorded layers and the balks only removed after the excavation of the site is complete. This method does not expose structures in a consistent manner as the layer method does nor is it a good choice for sites that will be presented to the public. Instead, it is intended to provide a clear and complete chronological sequence for the site.

Few excavators today follow a doctrinaire approach to excavation and a variety of methods are used based upon the research goals of the expedition. Much of the work being done in Israel, Jordan and the Palestinian Authority is salvage or “rescue” archaeology and surveys—both of them driven by the rapid pace of industrial and residential development in these countries.

Tuesday, January 1, 2008

The Bible in the Ancient Near East? Ideology and the Archaeology of the "Holy Land"

Middle Eastern Archaeology of periods after prehistory and before the Byzantine era is generally divided among Biblical, Ancient Near Eastern and Egyptological schools. Near Eastern archaeologists and Egyptologists habitually draw distinctions between their fields and that of “pre” (i.e., linguistically challenged) historians and anthropological archaeologists. Regardless of one’s orientation, however, the Bible looms large in the history of all of these disciplines. The development of Egyptian and Ancient Near Eastern archaeology was partially influenced by a general Christian religious interest in the lands mentioned in the Bible while the exploration of sites in Israel, Palestine and Jordan, was directly tied to an enlightenment-inspired belief that the Biblical text could be proven scientifically. Despite the fact that, after the founding of the State of Israel in 1948, this quest was partially transfomed by nationalist interests, the Bible continues to affect how sites are viewed by the public and by officials.

One story, perhaps apocryphal that has made the rounds of archaeologists in the region, for example, concerns a prominent prehistorian’s discovery of Upper Paleolithic human remains in one of the Carmel Caves. As required by law, he informed the religious authorities in Israel. These individuals normally take an avid interest in the discovery of skeletons, asserting that every human bone found in the Land of Israel today is deserving of a decent Jewish burial. The archaeologist was, to his relief, not to be deprived of his important find. Reportedly, he was told of this in a letter which, loosely translated, ceded jurisdiction over the remains because they appeared “to date from before creation.”

Nadia Abu El-Haj in Facts on the Ground describes Israeli Archaeology as consistently conflating text, dogmatic belief and practice but, in truth, this state of affairs predates the founding of the State of Israel by over one hundred years. The ideologies in question began with the written word. The Bible, “supported” by cuneiform tablets, papyri, scrolls and inscriptions, has a privileged status beyond that of mere artifact. One ignores the text at the peril of making one’s work irrelevant, as there are few who will refer to an archaeology of the “Holy Land” denuded of its associations with the Bible. Scholars who have attempted this to do this are dismissed by many of their colleagues as “minimalists.” The term is an interesting choice in that it implies a kind of austerely modern approach to archaeology. In any other context, it would connote an elimination of the extraneous—a reduction of a work to its most fundamental features suggesting that a minimalist approach would eliminate any consideration of the Biblical Text altogether. This is far from case, however, as a minimalist and a maximalist are both equally defined by their textual approach.

Ideology in the archaeology of the "Holy Land" effectively began in the late nineteenth century when exploration of the region by intrepid Europeans combined religion with an imperialist ethos of exploration for the sake of it and for the glory of the motherland. Starting in the twenties, others came—committed Christian religionists from European monasteries, Jesuit institutes, protestant and Jewish theological seminaries. The seminarians, as many of us refer to them, persist to this day, with a sizable percentage of the American Schools for Oriental Research, the organization of archaeologists in Palestine, being made up of ministers, priests and rabbis. It is this legacy that is the language and the means by which method has become informed. It is the primary reason why archaeology in this region is different from that practiced anywhere else in the world.